Two people go in for a rather invasive and somewhat painful surgical procedure. The nature of the procedure means that the can’t be anesthetized. To keep track of their pain, the physicians ask the patients to rate the level of pain they’re experiencing at regular intervals, from one to ten. Imagine this is charted below.
When the red line hits “0”, it’s because the procedure was done.
Some months later, on a follow-up, the patients are asked to describe their overall experience.
You would expect the patient whose responses that are plotted in blue in the chart above would report the experience being much worse. If you add all the numbers, this person’s average pain was higher, and they were in pain for much longer.
The patient whose responses are in red usually reports the experience being much worse than the patient whose responses are in blue, even though this person’s procedure was shorter, and they were in less pain overall. Why?
Endings matter.
The entire experience is profoundly influenced by that last memory. The patient in red ends in almost excruciating pain; the patient in blue ends with mild discomfort. And that last experience tends to be one that sticks.
This might explain why twist endings in movies and television and other stories are so divisive. They can be spectacularly successful or agonizingly bad. Sometimes a great ending saves an movie or episode and turns the run-of-the-mill into something quite amazing (e.g., The Sixth Sense). How many times have you been going alone, carried along with a story... and the ending ruins it, and you leave with a sour taste in your mouth? (E.g., Jacob’s Ladder.)
This talk - the most popular Ignite! talk to date - could be significantly improved:
This talk is popular because it is so useful. But the ending... a recap? What do you need a recap in a five minute talk for? Peoples’ memories aren’t that bad.
Nancy Duarte nailed what an ending should be in her book Resonate: a vision for a better tomorrow. She calls it, “the new bliss.” The new bliss sets out what could be, if the audience takes the story you have told them and acts on it.
Here’s a great example of an ending that lays out a new bliss. It’s Hans Rosling talking about the magic of washing machines:
A world with washing machines is not just a world with clean laundry. A world with washing machines is a world where machines have freed up time for parents to read books to their children.
In a scientific talk, the new bliss can be something as simple as a more complete understanding of some fine theoretic point that people in your field will appreciate. It could be ruling out an hypothesis. Or it could be a shifted paradigm. Or maybe there are big potential practical spin-offs that could come out of the work.
Put a lot of work into your endings.
Note: I heard the patient story on an online video somewhere; I thought it was on the TED website, but can’t find it gain. If anyone recognizes this and can point me to it, I would be most grateful!
14 March 2012
13 March 2012
Tuesday Crustie: Headline news
Because really, kids should be getting IACUC training much earlier.
Okay, this is a cheat: there is no actual crustacean in this picture. But I love this headline too much. Better without context.
Photo by Gerry Balding on Flickr; used under a Creative Commons license.
12 March 2012
Neuroscientists Talk Shop
When I was at the University of Texas San Antonio last week, I recorded an interview with them for their Neuroscientists Talk Shop podcast. Mine is now up. It’s mostly about nociception, although the connectome post I published last week also came up.
In this interview, my co-author on the nociception paper, Sakshi Puri, talks a bit about getting emails from PETA. When we published our paper, I blogged about my worries that there would be some people who would not like it regardless of what the paper actually says. I was disappointed to learn I was right, after the amount of effort we put into the paper to prevent misunderstandings.
For the record, if any of you have a problem with my research, please include me in that conversation.
There are 80 other interviews in this series. For fellow neuroethologists, some that might be particularly interesting include:
Mine was so enjoyable and the questions were so good, I plan go back and listen to a lot of episodes in their back catalog.
In this interview, my co-author on the nociception paper, Sakshi Puri, talks a bit about getting emails from PETA. When we published our paper, I blogged about my worries that there would be some people who would not like it regardless of what the paper actually says. I was disappointed to learn I was right, after the amount of effort we put into the paper to prevent misunderstandings.
For the record, if any of you have a problem with my research, please include me in that conversation.
There are 80 other interviews in this series. For fellow neuroethologists, some that might be particularly interesting include:
- David Perkel on bird song
- Karen Bales on primate bonding
- Peter Narins on acoustic communication
- Mike Smotherman on bat vocalizations
- Suzana Herculano-Houzel on comparative brain sizes
- Brenton Cooper on bird song development
Mine was so enjoyable and the questions were so good, I plan go back and listen to a lot of episodes in their back catalog.
09 March 2012
UTSA talk
On Wednesday, I drove up to San Antonio to give a talk and meet the fine folks in the University of Texas San Antonio neuroscience group. Because I had decided to talk about nociception, Sakshi Puri came along with me. We got to San Antonio early enough Wednesday that we were able to play a little hooky, and decided that it was a lovely day to go to the zoo. We saw this massive guy there:
Biggest snapping turtle I have ever seen. It looked like it was a million years old.
Thursday went very well. We met lots of people who were doing interesting science but who weren’t waaaaay into themselves. My feature talk was well received, had a mini-Tweet-up (one person who was following me from the Ecology meeting last summer!), followed by lunch with students.
We then recorded an interview of Neuroscientists Talk Shop. My interview isn’t up yet; I’ll let you know when it it. But there are plenty of other interviews there for the neurocurious (76, I think). Just the thing to keep your mind working through an exercise routine, say! We talked about nociception and yesterday’s connectome post.
One of the unexpected things I learned on this trip from my host, Todd Troyer: How to catch a zebra finch.
If a zebra finch escapes in your room, wait until it lands. Note where it is. Then turn off the lights, and reach and grab where it was.
These guys completely shut down when the light goes out. In a room full of chattering birds, the silence was so sudden when we flipped the light switch out that it seemed as though the switch was connected to the birds and the lights both. I just couldn’t get over how immediate and complete the silence was, and how quickly they started up again when the lights went back on.
After the visits, we went to The Monterey Restaurant. The website does not at all convey the great, funky feeling of the place. It also features the most... different... desert I think I have ever had: the cheese-plate pop-tart. It’s a slightly surreal combination of sweetness and, well, cheese. I was glad that I had it, because it was a taste unlike any other I can ever remember experiencing. I’m not sure I would order it again.
Thanks to all the students and faculty at UTSA for making it such a fun day for us!
Biggest snapping turtle I have ever seen. It looked like it was a million years old.
Thursday went very well. We met lots of people who were doing interesting science but who weren’t waaaaay into themselves. My feature talk was well received, had a mini-Tweet-up (one person who was following me from the Ecology meeting last summer!), followed by lunch with students.
We then recorded an interview of Neuroscientists Talk Shop. My interview isn’t up yet; I’ll let you know when it it. But there are plenty of other interviews there for the neurocurious (76, I think). Just the thing to keep your mind working through an exercise routine, say! We talked about nociception and yesterday’s connectome post.
One of the unexpected things I learned on this trip from my host, Todd Troyer: How to catch a zebra finch.
If a zebra finch escapes in your room, wait until it lands. Note where it is. Then turn off the lights, and reach and grab where it was.
These guys completely shut down when the light goes out. In a room full of chattering birds, the silence was so sudden when we flipped the light switch out that it seemed as though the switch was connected to the birds and the lights both. I just couldn’t get over how immediate and complete the silence was, and how quickly they started up again when the lights went back on.
After the visits, we went to The Monterey Restaurant. The website does not at all convey the great, funky feeling of the place. It also features the most... different... desert I think I have ever had: the cheese-plate pop-tart. It’s a slightly surreal combination of sweetness and, well, cheese. I was glad that I had it, because it was a taste unlike any other I can ever remember experiencing. I’m not sure I would order it again.
Thanks to all the students and faculty at UTSA for making it such a fun day for us!
08 March 2012
Overselling the connectome
In the last few years, there has been much discussion about the prospect of tracking the neural connections of mammalian, and particularly human, brains at very high levels of detail. Following the concept of a genome – every gene in an organism – a connectome is a map of every anatomical connection between every neuron in an organism.
One of the major proponents of this effort has been Sebastian Seung, who you can see giving a TED talk here. He sells the idea that understanding the human connectome will help us understand human identity. In his talk, Seung encourages his audience to say along with him. “I am my connectome.” He’s written a new book on this subject, Connectome: How the Brain’s Wiring Makes Us Who We Are.
This is an ambitious research project that will no doubt yield highly improved techniques to get anatomical information and analyze it. We will learn a lot from it.
And it will fail.
The allure, promise, and shortcomings of the connectome approach are yesterday’s news to neuroethologists. In the 1960s and 1970s, neuroethologists put in a lot of effort to crack partial connectomes of several species. These were usually referred to as “circuits” or “wiring diagrams.” (“Connectome” only appeared when neuroscientists got genome envy.) We made good progress on these. For example, we can explain escape behaviour in fishes and crayfish by the main synaptic connection between the critical neurons. That said, escape systems were chosen specifically because they were unusual behaviours. they are very sterotyped, very fast, and dedicated to one single task.
As other circuits were cracked, they revealed a much more subtle story.
A new paper by Bargmann details the case histories of a few of the species that neuroethologists have basically cracked the circuit. And contrary to some expectations, getting the complete set of synaptic connections did not solve the problems of understanding behaviour. I’m very glad that Bargmann wrote this paper, because it saves me the trouble of writing a much longer blog post.
For example, the nematode worm Caenorhabditis elegans has 302 neurons, and all the connections between them are known (the first complete connectome in the animal kingdom). Bargmann writes:
One of the major lessons that emerged in the 1990s from the study of these small circuits where we knew all the synaptic connections was the importance of neuromodulation. Neurons’ functions were not set only by their anatomical connections. They were profoundly influenced by a cocktail of neuroactive chemicals that could change the physiological responses of neurons.
Bargmann breaks it down. First, she shows that only rarely can you link single neurons to single behaviours. Then, she shows how one behaviour can result from several circuits, and how one neuromodulator can influence several behaviours. She notes that given how neuromodulation has appeared pretty much in every nervous system where we’ve looked, there’s every reason to expect it’s going to be a major factor in determining human neural activity, and thus, human identity.
In his TED talk, Seung draw an extended metaphor that the connectome is like the bed of a river.
Knowing the bed of the river still doesn’t tell you everything. The same river bed can have a trickle one day, and a flash flood the next. Neuromodulation is a bit like a dam partway along the river. It can regulate whether you have a torrent or a trickle.
Bargmann and I agree that connectome projects are very useful. But they alone will not solve the question of human identity. But at least when they fail, they will fail in an interesting way.
Reference
Bargmann C. 2012. Beyond the connectome: How neuromodulators shape neural circuits. BioEssays: In press. DOI: 10.1002/bies.201100185
One of the major proponents of this effort has been Sebastian Seung, who you can see giving a TED talk here. He sells the idea that understanding the human connectome will help us understand human identity. In his talk, Seung encourages his audience to say along with him. “I am my connectome.” He’s written a new book on this subject, Connectome: How the Brain’s Wiring Makes Us Who We Are.This is an ambitious research project that will no doubt yield highly improved techniques to get anatomical information and analyze it. We will learn a lot from it.
And it will fail.
The allure, promise, and shortcomings of the connectome approach are yesterday’s news to neuroethologists. In the 1960s and 1970s, neuroethologists put in a lot of effort to crack partial connectomes of several species. These were usually referred to as “circuits” or “wiring diagrams.” (“Connectome” only appeared when neuroscientists got genome envy.) We made good progress on these. For example, we can explain escape behaviour in fishes and crayfish by the main synaptic connection between the critical neurons. That said, escape systems were chosen specifically because they were unusual behaviours. they are very sterotyped, very fast, and dedicated to one single task.
As other circuits were cracked, they revealed a much more subtle story.
For example, the nematode worm Caenorhabditis elegans has 302 neurons, and all the connections between them are known (the first complete connectome in the animal kingdom). Bargmann writes:
At a more profound level, however, the wiring diagram was and remains difficult to read. The neurons are heavily connected with each other, perhaps even overconnected – it is possible to chart a path from virtually any neuron to any other neuron in three synapses. ... Circuit studies suggest a reason for this failure: there is no one way to read the wiring diagram.
One of the major lessons that emerged in the 1990s from the study of these small circuits where we knew all the synaptic connections was the importance of neuromodulation. Neurons’ functions were not set only by their anatomical connections. They were profoundly influenced by a cocktail of neuroactive chemicals that could change the physiological responses of neurons.
Bargmann breaks it down. First, she shows that only rarely can you link single neurons to single behaviours. Then, she shows how one behaviour can result from several circuits, and how one neuromodulator can influence several behaviours. She notes that given how neuromodulation has appeared pretty much in every nervous system where we’ve looked, there’s every reason to expect it’s going to be a major factor in determining human neural activity, and thus, human identity.
In his TED talk, Seung draw an extended metaphor that the connectome is like the bed of a river.
I would like to propose a metaphor for the relationship between neural activity and connectivity. Neural activity is constantly changing. It's like the water of the stream; it never sits still. The connections of the brain's neural network determines the pathways along which neural activity flows. And so the connectome is like bed of the stream; but the metaphor is richer than that, because it's true that the stream bed guides the flow of the water, but over long timescales, the water also reshapes the bed of the stream. And as I told you just now, neural activity can change the connectome. And if you'll allow me to ascend to metaphorical heights, I will remind you that neural activity is the physical basis – or so neuroscientists think – of thoughts, feelings and perceptions. And so we might even speak of the stream of consciousness. Neural activity is its water, and the connectome is its bed.
Knowing the bed of the river still doesn’t tell you everything. The same river bed can have a trickle one day, and a flash flood the next. Neuromodulation is a bit like a dam partway along the river. It can regulate whether you have a torrent or a trickle.
Bargmann and I agree that connectome projects are very useful. But they alone will not solve the question of human identity. But at least when they fail, they will fail in an interesting way.
Reference
Bargmann C. 2012. Beyond the connectome: How neuromodulators shape neural circuits. BioEssays: In press. DOI: 10.1002/bies.201100185
07 March 2012
Go Barsoom!
I am excited that Edgar Rice Burroughs’s John Carter of Mars is coming to the movie theatres*, just in time for its hundredth anniversary.
While the story has a lot of trappings that we’ve come to associate with high fantasy (swords, princesses, and the like), I want to make the case that A Princess of Mars is truly science fiction. And despite that it’s early science fiction, and that scientific knowledge has moved on in the last century, Burroughs got something right. Indeed, it’s something that later, ostensibly more sophisticated science fiction tends to gloss over, particularly in film and television.
Gravity.
Mars, Burroughs reminds us, has lighter gravity than Earth. Lower gravity means that John Carter, a Virginia everyman, becomes stronger than he ever would be on Earth. (Later, Superman’s would repeat the twist, with Krypton and Earth substituting for Earth and Mars.) The scientific fact about this basic force of nature is woven into the warp and weft of the books, and is never forgotten.
In contrast, gravity is ignored in most popular science fiction. People walk around on spaceships in the middle of interstellar travel as though they were on a building, not in weightlessness.
Occasionally, you’ll hear some one-liner tossed off about “artificial gravity generators” or some such to explain this. This is a good time to remember that of the four fundamental forces we know in this universe – gravity, the strong nuclear force, and the weak nuclear force, and electromagnetism – we can only manipulate the last of those. Physicists are still betting on whether the Large Hadron Collider will finally reveal why things have mass.
I sympathize with filmmakers. Trying to simulate weightlessness is tricky, and requires complicates special effects. But I do wish that they would address it more often. And judging from the previews, I’m happy that the makers of John Carter have chosen to embrace this aspect of the story, and that it is given due credit as the science fiction pioneer that it is.
* This is despite Disney giving the film the most boring and nonevocative logo in memory. Akzidenz-Grotesk? This does not convey any of the familiarity of the turn of the Victoria era or the alien nature of the Martian landscape. And the title isn’t much better. Just John Carter? Not even John Carter of Mars?
Book cover from here, a great site that contains lots of information and artwork from many printings of the story. For me, Frank Frazetta’s interpretation of Barsoom is definitive.
While the story has a lot of trappings that we’ve come to associate with high fantasy (swords, princesses, and the like), I want to make the case that A Princess of Mars is truly science fiction. And despite that it’s early science fiction, and that scientific knowledge has moved on in the last century, Burroughs got something right. Indeed, it’s something that later, ostensibly more sophisticated science fiction tends to gloss over, particularly in film and television.
Gravity.
Mars, Burroughs reminds us, has lighter gravity than Earth. Lower gravity means that John Carter, a Virginia everyman, becomes stronger than he ever would be on Earth. (Later, Superman’s would repeat the twist, with Krypton and Earth substituting for Earth and Mars.) The scientific fact about this basic force of nature is woven into the warp and weft of the books, and is never forgotten.
In contrast, gravity is ignored in most popular science fiction. People walk around on spaceships in the middle of interstellar travel as though they were on a building, not in weightlessness.
Occasionally, you’ll hear some one-liner tossed off about “artificial gravity generators” or some such to explain this. This is a good time to remember that of the four fundamental forces we know in this universe – gravity, the strong nuclear force, and the weak nuclear force, and electromagnetism – we can only manipulate the last of those. Physicists are still betting on whether the Large Hadron Collider will finally reveal why things have mass.
I sympathize with filmmakers. Trying to simulate weightlessness is tricky, and requires complicates special effects. But I do wish that they would address it more often. And judging from the previews, I’m happy that the makers of John Carter have chosen to embrace this aspect of the story, and that it is given due credit as the science fiction pioneer that it is.
* This is despite Disney giving the film the most boring and nonevocative logo in memory. Akzidenz-Grotesk? This does not convey any of the familiarity of the turn of the Victoria era or the alien nature of the Martian landscape. And the title isn’t much better. Just John Carter? Not even John Carter of Mars?
Book cover from here, a great site that contains lots of information and artwork from many printings of the story. For me, Frank Frazetta’s interpretation of Barsoom is definitive.
06 March 2012
Carnivals for March 2012
The Carnival of Evolution #45 is up at Splendour Awaits. The first slideshow in this carnival’s history, I think!
Circus of the Spineless #70 is at Beasts in a Populous City.
Circus of the Spineless #70 is at Beasts in a Populous City.
Tuesday Crustie: I’m not yellow... I just have yellow tips
Have no idea of the species of this crab, photographed in waters around New Guinea. I just love the yellow accents.
Photo by bbialek905 on Flickr; used under a Creative Commons license.
05 March 2012
“Kids”
I get annoyed whenever I hear university instructors, either in person or online, referring to their students as “kids.”
It’s disparaging. It’s dismissive. It undervalues their abilities and undercuts their views.
University students are adults. They don’t deserve to be tagged as children any more.
(Exceptions will be made for any student who is a goat.)
It’s disparaging. It’s dismissive. It undervalues their abilities and undercuts their views.
University students are adults. They don’t deserve to be tagged as children any more.
(Exceptions will be made for any student who is a goat.)
The Zen of Presentations, Part 51: Redrawn
“This is so ugly.”
I have been preparing for my talk at the University of Texas San Antonio this week. For context and background, I wanted to include some graphs from other, previously published papers as well as my own stuff. There were two problems.
First, the quality of the graphs I wanted to use wasn’t always there. Many were old, pixelated images. Some graphs had unlabelled error bars, and some had text overlapping with error bars. Some bar graphs had hatching to distinguish the bars that was not very pleasing to look at.
Second, the style of the images I wanted to use varied wildly. Some were monochrome, some used colour. Some used serif types, some used sans serif type. The shape of the graphs sometimes didn’t come anywhere near the shape of the slide.
Even with my own material, I was pulling together images from several years and projects – manuscripts, conference posters, unpublished stuff – and I was painfully aware that it didn’t fit together very well. As I’ve written about before, consistency matters.
So I redrew everything.
With my own material, this was tedious but straightforward. I just had to locate a lot of archived files on my hard drive, opened them up, and started changing fonts, colours, and proportions.
Making other people’s stuff consistent can be trickier. First, I typically had to grab images. For PDF files, there is a snapshot tool in Adobe Reader that lets you do grabs of anything on the screen. It isn’t turned on in the toolbar by default, though. Click at right to enlarge.
Once I have a grab of the graphic, I can then put it into a full graphics editor (I’m a Corel Photo-Paint user myself; other software packages are available). For instance, I can get rid of text that I don’t need or remove the background. But even PowerPoint can do some basic manipulations quite well.
For some graphs, I need to go right back to ground zero and redraw the graph in my own software. There is a shareware program called Datathief that I’ve used to get extract information from published graphs so I can replot it. It’s fairly simple to use for distinct data points, like scatter plots or bar charts. I haven’t tried to extract a curve yet.
I have heard that data extraction from published graphs is possible in Matlab, though I haven’t done it myself.
In the end, almost every image in my presentation has been altered, tweaked, cropped, redrawn, recoloured, resized, or revised. It took a few solid days to do it. I am convinced it’s worth it, though. The level of harmony in the talk is so much higher, and the overall effect of the presentation is so much stronger, than if I had just left it looking like a scrappy quilt.
Related posts
The Zen of Presentations, Part 41: Consistency
I have been preparing for my talk at the University of Texas San Antonio this week. For context and background, I wanted to include some graphs from other, previously published papers as well as my own stuff. There were two problems.
First, the quality of the graphs I wanted to use wasn’t always there. Many were old, pixelated images. Some graphs had unlabelled error bars, and some had text overlapping with error bars. Some bar graphs had hatching to distinguish the bars that was not very pleasing to look at.
Second, the style of the images I wanted to use varied wildly. Some were monochrome, some used colour. Some used serif types, some used sans serif type. The shape of the graphs sometimes didn’t come anywhere near the shape of the slide.
Even with my own material, I was pulling together images from several years and projects – manuscripts, conference posters, unpublished stuff – and I was painfully aware that it didn’t fit together very well. As I’ve written about before, consistency matters.
So I redrew everything.
With my own material, this was tedious but straightforward. I just had to locate a lot of archived files on my hard drive, opened them up, and started changing fonts, colours, and proportions.
Making other people’s stuff consistent can be trickier. First, I typically had to grab images. For PDF files, there is a snapshot tool in Adobe Reader that lets you do grabs of anything on the screen. It isn’t turned on in the toolbar by default, though. Click at right to enlarge.Once I have a grab of the graphic, I can then put it into a full graphics editor (I’m a Corel Photo-Paint user myself; other software packages are available). For instance, I can get rid of text that I don’t need or remove the background. But even PowerPoint can do some basic manipulations quite well.
For some graphs, I need to go right back to ground zero and redraw the graph in my own software. There is a shareware program called Datathief that I’ve used to get extract information from published graphs so I can replot it. It’s fairly simple to use for distinct data points, like scatter plots or bar charts. I haven’t tried to extract a curve yet.I have heard that data extraction from published graphs is possible in Matlab, though I haven’t done it myself.
In the end, almost every image in my presentation has been altered, tweaked, cropped, redrawn, recoloured, resized, or revised. It took a few solid days to do it. I am convinced it’s worth it, though. The level of harmony in the talk is so much higher, and the overall effect of the presentation is so much stronger, than if I had just left it looking like a scrappy quilt.
Related posts
The Zen of Presentations, Part 41: Consistency
Chocholate bar dissection
Last week, I was at a graduate student recruiting fair. To entice people towards my table, I stopped by the grocery store and picked up a variety pack of small chocolate bars. Contained within the package were Milky Way and Milky Way Midnight bars.
Until I had picked up one of these packages, I had never seen a Milky Way Midnight bar. I tried one, and oooooh, baby! They’re a bit of all right.
This left me with a puzzle. See, I’ve never been a big Milky Way fan. And this bar was obviously called Milky Way Midnight because it used dark chocolate, and I’ve never been a big dark chocolate fan, either. It’s okay (I mean, it is chocholate, after all), but I prefer the milk chocolate on the whole.
This called for more invasive techniques.
A-ha! Not only is the chocolate coating different, it has a different nougat inside! Milky Way Midnight has a vanilla nougat, and the regular Milky Way doesn’t. I think the difference. Because, as the Barenaked Ladies reminded us, vanilla is the finest of the flavours.
Until I had picked up one of these packages, I had never seen a Milky Way Midnight bar. I tried one, and oooooh, baby! They’re a bit of all right.
This left me with a puzzle. See, I’ve never been a big Milky Way fan. And this bar was obviously called Milky Way Midnight because it used dark chocolate, and I’ve never been a big dark chocolate fan, either. It’s okay (I mean, it is chocholate, after all), but I prefer the milk chocolate on the whole.
This called for more invasive techniques.
A-ha! Not only is the chocolate coating different, it has a different nougat inside! Milky Way Midnight has a vanilla nougat, and the regular Milky Way doesn’t. I think the difference. Because, as the Barenaked Ladies reminded us, vanilla is the finest of the flavours.
01 March 2012
A mountain is made of smaller stones
Earlier this week, I wrote about an article that claimed it’s too difficult to be a non-conforming researcher with new ideas because funding agencies are too conservative. I was gobsmacked that the author seemed to pick a case of HIV denial as an example of an “out of the box” idea that was worthy of pursuing rather than dismissing. This is doubly surprising when you consider that HIV research gives such a great example of the power of incremental research.
There is no cure for AIDS.
There is no vaccine for HIV.
But treatment has improved significantly.
I remember when nobody knew about AIDS. When I was in grad school, CBC Vancouver made the Dr. Peter Diaries, a series of documentaries of a physician who had AIDS. I remember how you could see his condition deteriorating as the diary progressed.
I’m sure that people in the HIV field (which I am not) can point to important papers in the development of those treatments. But from my point of view as an outsider, the overall pattern is one of a lot of researchers making many contributions. And it’s extraordinary to think that we’ve gone from a standing start to understanding and some degree of management in only part of an adult’s lifetime.
Naysayers are free to argue, of course, alternative histories where we gave money to non-conforming scientists with more daring ideas, and we’d have a cure, a vaccine, unlimited rice pudding, et cetera, et cetera. But this is speculative historical fiction, like, “What if Hitler won World War II?” It’s a fun hypothetical conversation, but it isn’t evidence.
External links
Academic: Slowing down the search for cures?
Are we playing too safe in cancer research?
Gapminder data on HIV deaths
There is no cure for AIDS.
There is no vaccine for HIV.
But treatment has improved significantly.
I remember when nobody knew about AIDS. When I was in grad school, CBC Vancouver made the Dr. Peter Diaries, a series of documentaries of a physician who had AIDS. I remember how you could see his condition deteriorating as the diary progressed.
I’m sure that people in the HIV field (which I am not) can point to important papers in the development of those treatments. But from my point of view as an outsider, the overall pattern is one of a lot of researchers making many contributions. And it’s extraordinary to think that we’ve gone from a standing start to understanding and some degree of management in only part of an adult’s lifetime.
Naysayers are free to argue, of course, alternative histories where we gave money to non-conforming scientists with more daring ideas, and we’d have a cure, a vaccine, unlimited rice pudding, et cetera, et cetera. But this is speculative historical fiction, like, “What if Hitler won World War II?” It’s a fun hypothetical conversation, but it isn’t evidence.
External links
Academic: Slowing down the search for cures?
Are we playing too safe in cancer research?
Gapminder data on HIV deaths
Comments for second half of February 2012
Jerry Coyne saw more than cuteness in the miniature chameleons (he saw lizard genitalia), but not the conservation aspect.
Jacqueline Gill looks at how a plant grew after tens of thousands of years in a deep freeze. Impressive, but I am not so sure it is ecologically relevant.
The Annals of Improbably Research asks what else bears do in the woods, which concerns research I also covered.
Drugmonkey argues that co-first authorship is a sham.
Jacqueline Gill looks at how a plant grew after tens of thousands of years in a deep freeze. Impressive, but I am not so sure it is ecologically relevant.
The Annals of Improbably Research asks what else bears do in the woods, which concerns research I also covered.
Drugmonkey argues that co-first authorship is a sham.
29 February 2012
I’m in Nature! Again‽
Back last October, I mentioned I was quoted briefly in Nature for an article on retractions.
Here it is, less than four months later, and I’m not only being quoted in Nature again, but more extensively. This time, it’s on matters arising from my Better Posters blog. I imagine there will be Nature readers will be thinking, “Him again?”
The article is available for free at the Nature Jobs website.
Reference
Powell K. 2012. Billboard science. Nature 483: 113-115. http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nj7387-113a
Designing the Open Lab 2013 buttons
I’ve been pleased to have designed the submission buttons for the last three editions of The Open Laboratory anthology of online science writing (read Bora Zivcovic’s account here). That said, I was surprised when Bora emailed me asking for a new one, because a year ago, I wrote:
I hope that Bora and the Open Lab team will let me retire this design after Open Lab 2011 is published. I’d like to see something fresh for the Open Lab 2012 buttons, whether from me or someone else.
I wanted to do something completely different.
I had a concept in my head, but it was complicated. Without getting into the details (because I might still try it next year), I couldn’t pull it off. I procrastinated and felt guilty knowing that Bora was waiting.
Finally, a week or two ago, I was thinking how to convey the concept of something being “open.” I thought of an open window looking out to the sky
The design went quickly from there.
I grabbed a picture of a beautiful skyline. It had to have some clouds to be recognizable as sky, rather than a just blue. I enlarged the “O” to maximize the amount of sky visible though it.
Because the idea was to be looking through something onto the sky, I wanted the background to look like a wall. I went into Corel Photo-Paint and played around with textures. Bricks were too rigid and too structured and visually noisy, so I used a simple stone texture.
I wanted colours that would “pop” against the colours of the sky. I used the eyedropper tool to sample the RGB values of the sky blue, then used Kuler to find complementary colours. It suggested a lovely dark tan as the main contrast colour, so that became the colour of the “Open Lab” text.
The darker blue Kuler suggested as part of the colour scheme seemed right for the “Submit to” text. Enlarging the “O” created a space for the “Submit to” text, but because that space was smaller than previous years, the text needed to be more condensed. I opened up the drop down menu, and found MoolBoran almost immediately. I went back and tried other similar fonts, but nothing seemed to fit the bill as well.
Things were starting to shape up. The colour scheme had a light brown, so I decided to make the stone texture that colour. I wasn’t quite sure how to do that, because the texture had been created in black and white. I draw a box underneath the stone texture, filled it with the light tan colour, and looked for a tool to make the stone transparent.
The transparency tool I found did not do what I wanted. I wanted to make the stone background equally transparent, but this was a dynamic tool. As a result, I got a totally unplanned gradient, which added some nice shades that highlighted the “O.”
Remember, love your accidents.
Now I was roughly at this point:
I liked it, but there were still some issues, like the line spacing. The colour scheme? It was lovely and calming. It made me think of beautiful tropical beaches. But it was too subdued, particularly given that the last two years had gone for intense colour schemes (boiling lava two years ago and action movie orange and blue last year).
The last tweak was to bring a more visual interest by adding another typeface. Because the other typefaces were very geometric, I looked for something more relaxed and “swishy” to contrast to them. Scriptina was one of the first ones I tried. As with the “Submit” text, I went back and tried some other brush scripts, but none seemed to work as well as Scriptina. It fit the available space perfectly, and I loved how the “2” was almost hugging the “B.”
Though I say it myself, I think the result is rather lovely. It’s not as radically different as I originally planned, but it is different enough that it stands apart from the last three years.
And if you read something you like here or on any other science blog, don’t forget to click the button!
Related posts
Open Lab 2011 begins! Plus: About the buttons
Open Laboratory 2009 candidate logo design
28 February 2012
Not every radical idea is right
As it stands, our current system may work well in weeding out technically flawed proposals and advancing incremental work, yet truly novel ideas will rarely be funded or even tolerated.
This is not a particularly new insight. I’ve written about it from time to time; see here. I think we disagree on the value of incremental work, though. I think most scientific progress comes from incremental work, while Nicholson seems to think we get progress from “out of the box” thinking. Nicholson asks:
If, historically, most new ideas in science have been considered heretical by experts, does it make sense to rely upon experts to judge and fund new ideas?
It is true that some now accepted ideas in science were disputed at first, but Nicholson does not seem to consider that not every “novel idea” is ultimately vindicated. Case in point:
The emphasis on being liked by the scientific community as a prerequisite to survive as a practicing scientist subsequently limits critical exchange in science. This is the case with Peter Duesberg who went from a prestigious 7-year outstanding investigator grant from the NIH to grant-less ever since because he questioned the role of oncogenes in cancer and the role of HIV in AIDS.
You’re going to use HIV denial to build your case? Seriously? In a spectacular “own goal,” Nicholson inadvertently demonstrates exactly why funding agencies are conservative: because there are some people out there who have ideas that are just wrong. There are ideas that are not worth pursuing.
And I did a double take when I read this in the acknowledgements:
I thank Peter Duesberg (UC Berkeley) for useful comments and suggestions(.)
It might not be best form to use someone who gave you feedback on an article as an example of someone who’s been treated unfairly. This is in an article that complains about how “who you know” is contaminating science.
Nicholson says:
The novelty of an idea can be measured by how many ideas and people it contradicts.
Alas, the insanity of an idea can be measured in precisely the same way.
At the end of the article, Nicholson proposes a couple of ways out of dealing with fuddy-duddy old boys’s network of granting agencies. One is to incorporate more non-scientists into the review process. I might argue that we’ve seen some of the outcomes of non-scientists getting involved in the scientific process whenever we hear about politicians ragging on certain projects as “wasteful.”
Another solution, Nicholson argues, is crowdfunding. Having been involved in a crowdfunding project (SciFund), I’ve heard concerns that cranks will use crowdfunding to get money for their goofy projects. I think that crowdfunded research projects should have some form of peer review to keep out the crazies.
Reference
Nicholson J. 2012. Collegiality and careerism trump critical questions and bold new ideas: A student's perspective and solution. BioEssays: in press. DOI: 10.1002/bies.201200001
Tuesday Crustie: I bless the rains down in Africa
A lovely picture of a freshwater crab in the family Potamonautidae from West Africa.
Photo by brian.gratwicke on Flickr; used under a Creative Commons license.
27 February 2012
A day in the field
I have a project that is requiring monthly collection at the beach on South Padre Island. The weather hasn’t been great, or I’ve had other tasks to do, most of February. This meant I almost had to go out and collect this weekend.
I was surprised when I got there, because “blue” is not a colour I normally see a lot of on our beach.
And going closer, I realized...
That this was a veritable invasion of Portuguese men of war.
Despite my best efforts to avoid them, one caught in a retreating wave got its tentacles on my shins. And I can now say with certainty that this is not an experience I recommend. I would call it a stinging, burning sort of sensation. Rather like a localized sunburn.
Fortunately, the water was chilly, so the coolness of the water numbed the sensation. Somewhat.
I also learned that the covers of Rite in the Rain all weather notebooks are almost exactly the same colour as the sand on South Padre Island, which means if, say, a notebook were to fall down to the sand on the beach, it can be rather difficult to see.
Furthermore, while Rite in the Rain products – such as their No. 37 pen – are indeed waterproof, they aren’t sand proof. And I discovered sand can get into all sorts of places that can gum up the works of a pen.
The things one does for data.
Excuse me... datum. “Data” is plural, so we would need to have found more than one animal to have data.
Last pic from here.
I was surprised when I got there, because “blue” is not a colour I normally see a lot of on our beach.
And going closer, I realized...
That this was a veritable invasion of Portuguese men of war.
Despite my best efforts to avoid them, one caught in a retreating wave got its tentacles on my shins. And I can now say with certainty that this is not an experience I recommend. I would call it a stinging, burning sort of sensation. Rather like a localized sunburn.
Fortunately, the water was chilly, so the coolness of the water numbed the sensation. Somewhat.
I also learned that the covers of Rite in the Rain all weather notebooks are almost exactly the same colour as the sand on South Padre Island, which means if, say, a notebook were to fall down to the sand on the beach, it can be rather difficult to see.
Furthermore, while Rite in the Rain products – such as their No. 37 pen – are indeed waterproof, they aren’t sand proof. And I discovered sand can get into all sorts of places that can gum up the works of a pen.
The things one does for data.
Excuse me... datum. “Data” is plural, so we would need to have found more than one animal to have data.
Last pic from here.
24 February 2012
Models
“We did this experiment with a mouse model.”
What, like this?
Why not just say “mice” instead of “mouse model”?
If you want to say “mouse model,” make sure that you are clear what the mice are models of. Models are stand ins or representations for something else. In biomedical research, mice are models for human diseases. Saying, “We used a mouse model of human schizophrenia” or “mouse model of human obesity” is fine.
But for something like the genetics of fur colour on mate selection probably means the mouse are not a model for anything else, it’s just a straight up inquiry into mouse biology. Mice for mice’s sake.
What, like this?
Why not just say “mice” instead of “mouse model”?
If you want to say “mouse model,” make sure that you are clear what the mice are models of. Models are stand ins or representations for something else. In biomedical research, mice are models for human diseases. Saying, “We used a mouse model of human schizophrenia” or “mouse model of human obesity” is fine.
But for something like the genetics of fur colour on mate selection probably means the mouse are not a model for anything else, it’s just a straight up inquiry into mouse biology. Mice for mice’s sake.
23 February 2012
Walk up to that bear
“See that bear?”
“That one there? Yeah.”
“Go walk up to it.”
“What?”
“Go on. Just walk up to it.”
“Um...”
That’s the sort of dialogue I heard in my head with I read the title, “Behaviour of solitary adult Scandinavian brown bears (Ursus arctos) when approached by humans on foot.”
Large mammals and humans often don’t get along well, and this is true of bears, too. Bears are a threat to humans, and humans are a threat to bears. This particular bear species is not doing so well in the wild, with several countries having a few hundred to a few thousands.
The researchers located 30 bears that had been given radio collars. That way, the positions of the bears were known to the people walking towards them. Many, if not all of the bears, were approached multiple times, but those were at least two weeks apart. One to four people started almost a kilometer away from the bear. The observers’ path was always upwind of the bear, so the bear would have scent cues coming from the people and would be less likely to be surprised.
As part of the objective was to simulate hikers, the observers were keep a normal hiking pace and talk to each other. The authors noted, though:
I imagine some poor bear sitting in the forest thinking, “Hoooooo boy. That one’s crazy.”
Most of the time, even knowing where the bears were, people only managed to see them about 15% of the time. Typically (80% of the time), the bears walked away from where they had been. None of the bears ever showed any signs of aggression towards people.
It’s good news that humans have little to fear from these bears. I do worry, though, that the bears might have a bit more to worry about from humans. I used to work in Waterton Lakes National Park in Alberta (one of my favourite places on the planet, by the way), and hikers were always being warned about bears. The black bears and grizzlies in the region, while not aggressive, are not exactly retiring, either. And humans in those parks have gotten themselves into all sorts of trouble by doing stupid things around bears. I do worry that if people think that Scandinavian bears are mostly harmless, people might do incredibly stupid things around the bears (trying to get a picture, and so on.)
Reference
Moen G, Støen O, Sahlén V, Swenson J. 2012. Behaviour of solitary adult Scandinavian brown bears (Ursus arctos) when approached by humans on foot PLoS ONE 7(2): e31699. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0031699
Picture by ucumari on Flickr; used under a Creative Commons license.
“That one there? Yeah.”
“Go walk up to it.”
“What?”
“Go on. Just walk up to it.”
“Um...”
Large mammals and humans often don’t get along well, and this is true of bears, too. Bears are a threat to humans, and humans are a threat to bears. This particular bear species is not doing so well in the wild, with several countries having a few hundred to a few thousands.
The researchers located 30 bears that had been given radio collars. That way, the positions of the bears were known to the people walking towards them. Many, if not all of the bears, were approached multiple times, but those were at least two weeks apart. One to four people started almost a kilometer away from the bear. The observers’ path was always upwind of the bear, so the bear would have scent cues coming from the people and would be less likely to be surprised.
As part of the objective was to simulate hikers, the observers were keep a normal hiking pace and talk to each other. The authors noted, though:
When just one observer approached the bear, this person talked to him- or herself.
I imagine some poor bear sitting in the forest thinking, “Hoooooo boy. That one’s crazy.”
Most of the time, even knowing where the bears were, people only managed to see them about 15% of the time. Typically (80% of the time), the bears walked away from where they had been. None of the bears ever showed any signs of aggression towards people.
It’s good news that humans have little to fear from these bears. I do worry, though, that the bears might have a bit more to worry about from humans. I used to work in Waterton Lakes National Park in Alberta (one of my favourite places on the planet, by the way), and hikers were always being warned about bears. The black bears and grizzlies in the region, while not aggressive, are not exactly retiring, either. And humans in those parks have gotten themselves into all sorts of trouble by doing stupid things around bears. I do worry that if people think that Scandinavian bears are mostly harmless, people might do incredibly stupid things around the bears (trying to get a picture, and so on.)
Reference
Moen G, Støen O, Sahlén V, Swenson J. 2012. Behaviour of solitary adult Scandinavian brown bears (Ursus arctos) when approached by humans on foot PLoS ONE 7(2): e31699. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0031699
Picture by ucumari on Flickr; used under a Creative Commons license.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
















